- Just About Walking Most of the Route of Bucharest Marathon 2026 » »
- « « Guess CSM Losing to Borussia Was More Like a Sign of Things to Come…
A Belated Comment on Nightwish and Floor Parting Ways
This is last week’s news by now, but I can’t not comment on the announcement that, after 14 years together, Nightwish and Floor Jansen will go their separate ways. And at least this seems to be a pretty civilized separation, the common part of the announcement listing it as being done in mutual agreement and wishing each other nothing but the very best, even though the part she added does make it quite clear that it was her decision, while the part added by the band is clearly meant to prevent any discussions about an imminent end of Nightwish… Which would make sense, considering previous statements. But now they do seem to already have plans, Tuomas having already stated before this announcement that several songs are already written for the new album that’s set to be recorded next year, and those songs may well take into account the change in vocalist, because I doubt that this decision was reached all of a sudden, and in hindsight it may be said that recent interviews did seem to indicate that Floor and the band no longer had common plans for the near future… Not that Nightwish had been doing much of anything for quite a while.
That may, in fact, be one of the reasons for the split. I doubt I’m using too strong a term when I say that Floor just loved Nightwish, so this decision would have been particularly hard, but it might have gotten to the point of feeling that she was useless and just tied down to a band that was essentially turning into a studio project that would only be “activated” when Tuomas had everything ready and settled, and now that she has her own solo project, it was simply too inconvenient to have that held over her head and prevent her from really committing to her project. And then there’s Auri, which is where Tuomas’ attentions have been focused in recent years and where there’s obviously no room for her. And with Auri also including Troy and even Kai, most of Nightwish is now there, and it’s been quite some time since Tuomas’ songwriting seemed to go in that direction, with Nightwish moving towards something like Auri with an orchestra, which may be another good reason for someone with a deep love for the band as it was to have misgivings about the future and feel the need to move on. As a personal comment, I must also add that, however much I say that I’ll always stand by them, I’ve been drifting more and more away ever since Endless Forms Most Beautiful, since just those themes and lyrics which had drawn me to them and held me there for so many years were completely changed.
But, since I mentioned the other Nightwish members that are also in Auri, I need to point out that, now that Floor left, the only one that’s still left out is Emppu, and he doesn’t seem to have much else going on either, so it may well be that he’s the one who’s most determined to push for Nightwish to continue in some form, maybe even if it will fully become Auri with an orchestra. Or, I guess, an orchestra and an electric guitar. It may even be that he was the one who insisted on holding the band together when Marko left, when Tuomas was saying that his initial reaction was to say that it was over but then he talked to Emppu and they were going to continue. And now that they’re getting over this hiatus and will be recording again and starting a new “era”, it may be that there will be plenty more years to come, as long as Tuomas and, most probably, also Emppu will remain in good enough health.
The question is what form that future will hold, and I really couldn’t say. I mean, I keep wishing for a return to the old Nightwish, which could have definitely been achieved and likely even improved over all the years with Floor, but Tuomas was no longer in that mindset and there’s even less reason to think he’ll return anywhere near it from now on, so that’s a false hope. And the idea of Auri with an orchestra does seem more and more probable, and I wouldn’t even be entirely surprised if Johanna would be the new Nightwish vocalist, even if it’d likely mean leaving nearly all of their older songs behind, since her voice, however nice it is for the kind of music she does, definitely couldn’t handle it. Then again, Nightwish may actually transition to mainly a studio project, in which case being unable to perform the old songs won’t be an issue, and maintaining good relations with Floor, which I’m pretty sure will be the case, may well mean that she’ll step in if they’ll have the odd concert on certain occasions.
Would that be desirable? Definitely not. But they’ve been there for the past couple of years already, so it may well be what they’re still willing and able to do, at least considering their other projects as well. That still leaves Emppu out, but he may not be in a position to do much about it, and I’ll say again that he might have held the band together this long. And the label may also be content with still having some material to put out there instead of nothing, and they may even see benefits in one of their main acts sticking to recording albums that they’ll then retain full rights for and at most having a few major concerts that may be marketed individually and differently, and maybe also streamed, and not for free, and/or possibly recorded and then sold separately. So it is a probable scenario, even if it is an unpleasant one for fans, and for those of the old Nightwish even more so. But, even in this scenario, there will probably still be some highlights, like Lanternlight was on Yesterwynde, with The Children of ‘Ata and maybe also Hiraeth deserving mentions as well.



