- Remaining Odds and Ends from April and May of 2024 » »
- « « Just About Walking Most of the Route of Bucharest Marathon 2026
Quick Review: The CRPG Book – Expanded Edition
With the caveat that I really don’t think that at least a handful of the games should be considered RPGs, the selection of reviewed titles does strike me as surprisingly good overall, and plenty of the reviews tend to provide a good counterpoint for the nostalgia many may remember those games with, pointing out their many flaws, how forgiving players were, the bad bugs and the patches that existed even “in the old days”, plus how often games were ruined by publishers in just about every “era”. And reading those reviews in order also offers a good overview of CRPGs through the ages, also largely confirming my view that, after nearly everything being way too punishing and rough for a long time, there was a gradual improvement that led to a “golden age”, which was followed by a brief apparent collapse and then by a revival that’s still ongoing but which comes with the genre morphing and splitting ever more, leading to my interest being confined to an ever smaller piece of an admittedly ever bigger pie.
However, this is not a quick read, those reviews that make up the main part being pretty short but having notes and quotes on the side and for screenshots, and bits about mods. Yet what’s worse is that there are many, many different authors, the reviews varying wildly in style, scope and quality, and it’s unpleasant to still see so many typos in something revised multiple times over several years. Plus that sometimes you have reviews for every game in a series, and even a few for expansions, but many others cover entire series, sometimes the listed title even being from the middle of it. And the listed release year is questionable in plenty of cases. So I actually found the sections and articles that come before and after the reviews much more interesting, reading more like an actual book and providing good insight into CRPG history and relevance, so from my point of view it’s unfortunate that the niche topics are covered in that manner instead of the core part.
Rating: 3/5



